Where Care Excellence Meets Business Success. Transform your operations today - 0333 577 0877
We are here to help 24/7.

Inspection and compliance10:27

Your Carer Was Accused of Abuse at ANOTHER Job. What You Must Do

A carer tells you that a person at her other job has accused her of abuse and the police are involved. What your duties are under Regulations 13 and 18, and the steps to take straight away.

In this video

Transcript

2,132 words, about 9 minutes to read. Press a time to play from that moment.

  1. Introduction: The Scenario Explained

    Hi, and welcome back to our page. One of your carers comes to you and says, "I need to tell you something. At my other job, a service user has accused me of sexual abuse during personal care. The police have been called, and the other employer has taken statements." And now, the carer is standing in front of you telling you everything, being completely open and transparent about it.

  2. She's got a great relationship with your service users. They love her. They've never been any concerns, and she's telling you voluntarily, which feels like the right thing to do. So, what do you do? Do you keep her working, or do you suspend her? Do you tell CQC? Do you tell your safeguarding board? Does any of this even involve you, given that it happened somewhere else?

  3. This is one of the hardest situations you will face as a provider, and I see people getting it wrong all the time. So, let me walk you through exactly what you need to do step by step, and most importantly, why. I know what some of you are thinking. It didn't happen in my service. It's not my investigation.

  4. Why would I need to do anything? And I understand that reaction. I really do. But let me explain why your thinking gets you into serious trouble. Under regulation 13 of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 Regulated Activities Regulations 2014, you have a duty to establish and operate effective systems to prevent abuse.

  5. Key Question: What Should the Provider Do?

    That's not limited to abuse that happens in your service. It covers any risk of abuse to the people you support. The carer who is under active police investigation for sexual abuse allegation is, by definition, a risk that you need to assess and manage. Think about it from CQC's perspective.

  6. If this carer continues working with your service users, and something happens, the first question an inspector will ask is, "When did you know?" And the second question will be, "What did you do about it?" This is what we call a person in a position of trust concern. Your local safeguarding adults board will have a protocol for exactly this type of scenario.

  7. And that protocol applies regardless of where the alleged abuse took place, because the concern is something about a person, not the setting. Here's exactly what you need to do. Step one, remove the carer from direct care duties immediately. I know that sounds harsh, especially when this person has been brilliant with your service users, but this isn't a punishment, it's a safeguarding measure.

  8. Legal Duty Under Safeguarding Regulations

    You're protecting your service users, you're protecting the carer, and you're protecting yourself as a provider.

  9. Now, does this mean formal suspension? Not necessarily. Acas guidance is very clear that suspension should be a last resort, not a knee-jerk reaction. You need to consider alternatives first. Could you move them to a non-care facing role temporarily? Office duties, administrative tasks, training? If you can do that, it may be more proportionate than a full suspension. But here's the reality for most domiciliary care providers.

  10. You don't have office roles to redeploy people into. Your staff are out in the community in people's homes, often working alone. There's no way to keep this person working without them having direct contact with vulnerable adults. And in that case, yes, suspension on full pay is the right course of action. It's not a disciplinary sanction, it's a neutral protective measure whilst the investigation takes its course.

  11. Document your rationale, write down why you've made this decision, and if you suspend, record the reasons. If you find an alternative suspension, record why that alternative adequately manages the risk. This documentation protects you at every stage. Step two, contact the local authority safeguarding team. I saw someone in a forum asking, "Do I need to tell safeguarding if it happened somewhere else?"

  12. Immediate Action: Remove from Direct Care

    And the answer is absolutely yes. Section 42 of the Care Act 2014 places a duty on the local authority to make inquiries when there's reasonable cause to suspect that an adult with care and support needs is experiencing or at risk of abuse. Your service users are adults with care and support needs. A carer under investigation for sexual abuse represents a potential risk to them.

  13. The local authority needs to know. And here's the thing that I always say. Imagine the worst-case scenario, imagine the allegations turn out to be true. Safeguarding will want to know why you didn't tell them. They'll ask when you became aware, and they'll want to see evidence that you acted on it. Similarly, if the allegations turn out to be unfounded, safeguarding will simply close the case.

  14. There's no downside to reporting. There's only downside to not reporting. Step three, notify CQC. Now, this gets nuanced, so listen carefully. The statutory notification under regulation 18 of the CQC registration regulations requires you to notify CQC of any allegation in relation to a service user.

  15. Suspension vs Alternative Duties

    Key question is whether the allegation relates to the carrying on of your regulated activity. Strictly speaking, the alleged abuse happened at another service, not yours. So, you could argue the notification is not technically required. But, my advice, and this is based on years of experience, is to notify CQC anyway. Here's why. CQC operates on a principle of candour and transparency.

  16. If you know that a member of your staff is under police investigation for a serious allegation, and you don't tell CQC, they'll find out later, and the question is, why did you not tell us? This looks like concealment. That damages trust, and that will absolutely be reflected in your inspection outcome under the well-led key question. Notification is simple.

  17. Log into the CQC provider portal and submit a safeguarding notification. Explain the situation factually, state what actions you've taken. It takes 10 minutes, and it puts you on the right side of the regulator. Step four, conduct a formal risk assessment. Don't just make a mental note that you've dealt with it.

  18. Write a formal risk assessment covering the nature of the allegation, the status of the police investigation, the actions you've taken to protect your service users, the impact on staffing and continuity of care, and the ongoing monitoring arrangements you've put in place.

  19. Step 2 & 3: Safeguarding Referral and CQC Notification

    Review the risk assessment regularly throughout the investigation. Police investigations can take months, sometimes longer. Your risk assessment needs to be a living document that you revisit and update. Step five, manage the carer properly during the investigation. If you suspend this person, you still have your duties towards them.

  20. Acas says suspension should be kept as short as possible, and the employer must keep the employee updated on the situation. Check in with them regularly, remind them of any employee assistance programme you might offer, and make it clear that suspension is not a finding of guilt. It's a precautionary measure.

  21. Also, ask the carer to keep you informed of any developments from the police investigation and any other employer. You need to know when the investigation concludes so you can take appropriate steps. Document every conversation and every update. Six, communicate with your service users. You said your service users love this carer and want her all the time.

  22. That means when she suddenly stops turning up, they're going to ask questions. Handle this carefully. You cannot share details of the investigation because there's an active police investigation and the carer has not been found guilty of anything, but you can say that the carer is currently unavailable and you're arranging alternative cover.

  23. Step 4 & 5: Risk Assessment and Ongoing Management

    If service users or their families press for details, explain that there's a confidential employment matter that prevents you from sharing more, but that their care will not be affected. Step seven, don't conduct your own investigation into the allegation. This is really important.

  24. The alleged abuse did not happen in your service, the police are investigating, it's not your place to interview the complainant, to gather evidence, or make findings about what you did or didn't happen. Your job is to manage the risk to your own service users and cooperate with the police and safeguarding if they ask for information.

  25. Once the police investigation concludes, you can then decide what internal action you're going to do. Let me tell you the mistakes I see providers making in situations like this, because I see them regularly. Mistake one, keeping the carer on duties because she's good at her job and your service users like her.

  26. I understand the temptation, but the quality of someone's work does not override a live safeguarding concern. You're not a court, you're not deciding guilt or innocence, you're managing risk, and right now the risk is unacceptable. Mistake two, only doing a supervision and thinking that's enough. A supervision meeting is a good start, but it's not a safeguarding response.

  27. Supervision is an employment tool. Safeguarding requires referrals, notifications, risk assessments, and documented decisions.

  28. Step 6: Communicating with Service Users

    They're not the same thing. Mistake three, not telling safeguarding or CQC because it happened elsewhere. I've already explained why this is wrong. The allegation may have happened elsewhere, but the risk to your service users exists right now in your service. Safeguarding and CQC need to know. Mistake four, suspending without any documented rationale. Some providers panic and immediately suspend without recording why.

  29. If the allegation turns out to be unfounded and the carer worker a claim against you, you need to show that your decision to suspend was reasonable, based on genuine risk, and that you considered alternatives. Acas is clear, suspension must have reasonable grounds. Document those grounds. I want to address something that comes up a lot in these situations.

  30. Providers feel torn because the care worker disclosed voluntarily. She came to you, she was honest, and now it feels like she's being punished for doing the right thing.

  31. Step 7: Do Not Investigate Yourself

    I hear that. And actually, credit to the care worker for being up front. That does matter. But being honest about the situation doesn't remove the risk. Doesn't change the fact that there's an active police investigation, and it doesn't change your legal and regulatory duties as a provider. What it does change is how you treat the person through the process.

  32. Be compassionate. Be clear that this is not judgement on them. Explain that you have duties you cannot ignore, and make it clear that once the investigation is resolved, if they are cleared, you will welcome them back. That's how you treat people fairly while still protecting everyone.

  33. And one more thing, if the other employer had that care worker on a zero-hour contract, and it was her first day, do check whether if she's suspended there, too. If she's not suspended by the other employer, you need to ask why. Because that raises its own concerns about their safeguarding governance.

  34. If she's suspended there on full pay, speak to Acas about who is liable for pay when someone has two employers. It can get complicated, and Acas will give you free impartial advice on that. Let me bring this together. When a member of your staff is accused of abuse, whether it happened in your service or somewhere else entirely, you have seven things you must do.

  35. Common Mistakes Providers Make

    Remove them from direct care duties. Contact your local safeguarding team. Notify CQC. Complete a formal risk assessment. Manage and support the care worker during the investigation. Communicate appropriately with your service users, and do not investigate the allegation yourself. Every single step needs to be documented. Every conversation, every decision, every rationale. Your evidence trail is your protection. And I know this is difficult.

  36. Nobody becomes a care provider because they enjoy dealing with safeguarding allegations. You get into this because you care about people. But caring about people is exactly why you have to follow this process. You're protecting your service users, you're protecting the carer from working under a cloud without proper process, and you're protecting your service from regulatory consequences.

  37. If you're going through something similar and you're not sure what to do, get in touch with us at Care Sync Experts. We deal with these situations regularly and we can guide you through it. Drop a comment below. However, before you come to us, I would always strongly advise you to check with your HR department or employment law services.

  38. Final Summary and Key Takeaways

    If you've been in this situation before, how did you handle it? Did you find the process straightforward or did you struggle with I want to hear from you because the more we talk about this openly, the better we will get at handling it. If you found this video helpful, make sure to like, comment, share, and subscribe and I'll catch you in the next one.

Transcribed from the video's captions and lightly edited. Where the wording differs, the video is the record.

Want help with this?

Tell us where you are now and we will tell you honestly what it will take, and what we would do first.

More on inspection and compliance

All inspection and compliance videos